Rate the 2010 German Grand Prix

TwistedArmco · Post by **TwistedArmco** » 25 Jul 2010, 17:25

This should be interesting...

1 - Best Driver
2 - Best Team
3 - Best Overtake
4 - Best Moment
5 - Worst Driver
6 - Worst Team
7 - Best Rookie
8 - Biggest Surprise

9 - General Comment(s)

dacer · Post by **dacer** » 25 Jul 2010, 17:34

1 - Best Driver
Faster man all the weekend, Alonso

2 - Best Team
Ferrari, very fast both car, 2+3 on grid, 1+2 on race

3 - Best Overtake
Alonso to Massa, and Massa to Alonso again, with two lapped cars and Vettel near.

4 - Best Moment
Race start, Vettel move very near and dangerous to Alonso, and Massa get first postition

5 - Worst Driver
Webber and Hamilton. Webber because his teammate was faster than him (supposed they have same car). Hamilton, because he is championship leader, and I didn't see him today

6 - Worst Team
McLaren, as bad as god Ferrari this weekend.

7 - Best Rookie
8 - Biggest Surprise
Ferrari on top again. The race was a fight Massa vs Vettel. If Vettel was closer then he "must" let Alonso overtake him. If Massa was faster (than Vettel) sure he would win

9 - General Comment(s)

JoostLamers · Post by **JoostLamers** » 25 Jul 2010, 17:39

I think it's better for me not to comment on this topic ánd not on the previous post. Can you confirm you understand this?

dacer · Post by **dacer** » 25 Jul 2010, 17:49

comment on
http://f1zone.net/viewtopic.php?f=51&t=5997&start=420

This is a "Rate" post

Sl2

shämito · Post by **shämito** » 25 Jul 2010, 17:57

1 - Best Driver
Massa, he deserved to win this race.

2 - Best Team
Let's say Red Bull

3 - Best Overtake
Massa on Vettel & Alonso at start.

4 - Best Moment
-

5 - Worst Driver
Yamamoto

6 - Worst Team
Ferrari, you all know why...

7 - Best Rookie
Petrov

8 - Biggest Surprise
Ferrari's team order

9 - General Comment(s)
Very boring race.. 3/10

Edi96 · Post by **Edi96** » 25 Jul 2010, 17:59

1 - Best Driver
Vettel

2 - Best Team
Red Bull

3 - Best Overtake
De la Rosa on Barrichello

4 - Best Moment
Schumacher vs. Kubica

5 - Worst Driver
Alonso... (Alguersuari)

6 - Worst Team
Ferrari... (Force India)

7 - Best Rookie
Petrov

8 - Biggest Surprise
Ferrari back on top

alex1369 · Post by **alex1369** » 25 Jul 2010, 18:11

1 - Best Driver -- Massa deserved to win this race but...
2 - Best Team -- Ferrari dominating all weekend
3 - Best Overtake -- MSC vs Kubica was good but no overtaking

4 - Best Moment -- well the start and thats it
5 - Worst Driver -- Torro Rosso drivers
6 - Worst Team -- Torro Rosso for taking each other out (they to give wings)

7 - Best Rookie -- Petrov in points
8 - Biggest Surprise -- that it was a boring race - i expected a lot more what we usually get here

9 - General Comment(s)

well what can i say, the most boring race of the season so far, even Bahrain was better (there were about 15 overtakings) and here not even 5

4/10

Tom Vandenhove · Post by **Tom Vandenhove** » 25 Jul 2010, 18:22

1 - Best Driver -- Felipe Massa, Ferrari shame on you!
2 - Best Team -- Ferrari, althought they don't deserve it at all.
3 - Best Overtake -- DLR on ... idk, forgot
4 - Best Moment -- Start of the race
5 - Worst Driver -- Buemi and Alguersuaro
6 - Worst Team -- Toro Rosso
7 - Best Rookie -- Vitaly Petrov !
8 - Biggest Surprise -- Ferrari scoring a 1-2

9 - General Comment(s) -- Why did I actually watch this ? Tour the france was probably way more exciting

3/10

TwistedArmco · Post by **TwistedArmco** » 25 Jul 2010, 19:18

1 - Best Driver
I think it probably goes to Massa for the fact he was ahead and would have won. I think Alonso was genuinely faster, but it's not easy to overtake, hence he couldn't.
2 - Best Team
Ferrari for pace.
3 - Best Overtake
One of De la Rosa's three on Hulk.
4 - Best Moment
Rob Smedley's sarcastic radio messages.
5 - Worst Driver
Probably Schumi, in context of his home race, maybe Sutil or Liuzzi, although that was arguably not their fault.
6 - Worst Team
Ferrari for handling what could have been an easy and discreet team-order terribly.
7 - Best Rookie
Kowboy? Petrov? Wasn't really focusing.
8 - Biggest Surprise
Well, I didn't expect them to actually let Alonso past. Ferrari has been decidedly more sensible in the last few years then the whole 2002 thing, so it slightly shocked and appalled me, I must admit.

9 - General Comment
Now for a start, the order should never have come. But secondly, why isn't there a more discreet radio command as code to let the guy behind by? And then, why couldn't Massa have just slowed slightly, just so Alonso could get in his slipstream? Or he could've "run wide" at turn 1, which he seemed happy to do for half the previous laps of the weekend. Like swca92 said, it's less the actual order (after all, McLaren and BMW have both done the old switcheroo in the last two years, although it didn't matter so much then) than the way it was carried out.

The race's only interesting bit was the start, the pistops and the mental battle between Alonso and Massa, while it lasted.

Thus:

Australian Grand Prix 9/10
Canadian Grand Prix 9/10
Chinese Grand Prix 9/10
Turkish Grand Prix 7/10
British Grand Prix 7/10
Monaco Grand Prix 7/10
Malaysian Grand Prix 7/10
European Grand Prix 6/10
Spanish Grand Prix 5/10
Bahrain Grand Prix 5/10
German Grand Prix 4/10

Post by **Zack** » 25 Jul 2010, 19:42

1 - Best Driver
?
2 - Best Team
? ..RBR
3 - Best Overtake
PDLR on one of williams
4 - Best Moment
"Sorry"
5 - Worst Driver
NA
6 - Worst Team
Virgin
7 - Best Rookie
Koya
8 - Biggest Surprise
Ferrari & ..Rob "sorry"

9 - General Comment
Race to forget .. waste of time ..shud hv gone for SALT

Earth · Post by **Earth** » 25 Jul 2010, 20:47

1 - Best Driver: Massa
2 - Best Team: Ferrari
3 - Best Overtake: De la Rosa on Hulkenberg
4 - Best Moment: JB in front of Webber
5 - Worst Driver: Alguersuari (hitting his teammate)
6 - Worst Team: Ferrari
7 - Best Rookie: Petrov
8 - Biggest Surprise: JB staying out on soft tyres for a long time

9 - General Comment(s): Don't really know what I have think about this race, there wasn't so much overtakes how was predticted and Ferrari's team orders so 4/10.

Denorth · Post by **Denorth** » 25 Jul 2010, 20:58

1 - Best Driver - Massa
2 - Best Team - McLaren, with not the best car using all situations on maximum
3 - Best Overtake - Massa on start over Vettel and Alonso
4 - Best Moment - I think JB diong good laps before pitstop
5 - Worst Driver - let it be Vettel for wasting his pole position second time in the row
6 - Worst Team - Ferrari
7 - Best Rookie - have no idea
8 - Biggest Surprise - Ferrari being so cynical

9 - General Comment(s) - one of the most boring races. most interesting part - two-hour after-race discussion about Alonso/Massa case. This is not something I want to watch F1 for. One may wonder why Silverstone was under the threat last year?

2/10

dazmoffman · Post by **dazmoffman** » 25 Jul 2010, 22:48

1 - Best Driver - massa lead the race frorm start to finish...........
2 - Best Team - ferrari very fast package
3 - Best Overtake - alonso on massa best over take ever
4 - Best Moment -alonso being so good he overtook massa
5 - Worst Driver - ?
6 - Worst Team - ferarri what a bunch of sh!ts, the prancing horse defacated into its most loyal employees.
7 - Best Rookie
8 - Biggest Surprise - dominicali and alonso playing everyone for fools

9 - General Comment(s) - waste of time left a sour taste in my mouth dont want to watch the replay as all i can smell is horse sh!t

harrisv48 · Post by **harrisv48** » 25 Jul 2010, 22:52

1 - Best Driver - Massa
2 - Best Team - McLaren and Red Bull
3 - Best Overtake - Massa on start over Vettel and Alonso
4 - Best Moment - Schumi vs Kubica
5 - Worst Driver - And the winner is....ALONSO you now why...
6 - Worst Team - Ferrari
7 - Best Rookie - Petrov
8 - Biggest Surprise - Ferrari not DSQ

9 - General Comment(s) - Boring race

Sanredrose · Post by **Sanredrose** » 25 Jul 2010, 23:35

1 - Best Driver - Massa
2 - Best Team - Mclaren
3 - Best Overtake - Schu on Rosberg
4 - Best Moment - JB putting some quick laps to counter Webber
5 - Worst Driver - Vettel
6 - Worst Team - RBR
7 - Best Rookie - NA
8 - Biggest Surprise - NA

9 - General Comment(s) - Boring race ...

Ferrari's team orders aren't a surprise to me. It was their policy in the past and some people never change.
Chris Horner should stop commenting on Ferrari when his own policy on driver preference was evident in Silverstone.
Vettel is beginning to annoy me, with his stupid move. Two races in succession this guy has tried run off or crash the P2 driver.
Mclaren had the guts to go with their under performing diffuser but they have finished where they would have with their old configuration.

F1Zone