Rate the 2011 German Grand Prix

Eric_Cartman · Post by **Eric_Cartman** » 24 Jul 2011, 16:53

1 - Best Driver
2 - Best Team
3 - Best Overtake
4 - Best Moment
5 - Worst Driver
6 - Worst Team
7 - Best Rookie
8 - Biggest Surprise

9 - General Comment(s)

Eric_Cartman · Post by **Eric_Cartman** » 24 Jul 2011, 17:00

1 - Best Driver - Lewis Hamilton. Sutil also had a great race
2 - Best Team - Force India
3 - Best Overtake - Hamilton on Webber
4 - Best Moment - the last lap
5 - Worst Driver - Buemi
6 - Worst Team - HRT
7 - Best Rookie - Perez
8 - Biggest Surprise - Vettel's slow pace

9 - General Comment(s) - 9/10 great action at the front.

JoostLamers · Post by **JoostLamers** » 24 Jul 2011, 17:11

1 - Best Driver - Lewis Hamilton
2 - Best Team - McLaren
3 - Best Overtake - Hamilton on Alonso exiting the pits. That did it.
4 - Best Moment - Realising Hamilton was going to win it

5 - Worst Driver - Chandhok
6 - Worst Team - HRT
7 - Best Rookie - Perez
8 - Biggest Surprise - No rain

9 - General Comment(s) 9/10, loved it. It was an epic battle between Hamilton, Alonso and Webber.

Post by **corry** » 24 Jul 2011, 17:18

1 - Best Driver - Lewis hamilton
2 - Best Team - Mclaren
3 - Best Overtake - Hamilton on Alonso
4 - Best Moment - Hamilton on alonso again lol
5 - Worst Driver - Buemi
6 - Worst Team - HRT
7 - Best Rookie - Rookie
8 - Biggest Surprise - Mclarens consistent pace

9 - General Comment(s)

Great 3 way battle loved it 9/10

Post by **phil1993** » 24 Jul 2011, 17:50

1 - Best Driver
Close between either Hamilton or Sutil. Hamilton's pace was stunning and his move around Alonso was that of a true champion, with Alonso giving him the respect as well. Sutil boosted Force India's points haul as well, and puts them firmly in 7th place

2 - Best Team
Probably Red Bull. Hadn't the pace but managed 3rd and 4th.

3 - Best Overtake
Hamilton on Alonso was superb

4 - Best Moment
Hamilton winning! Also, the first 20 laps were breathtaking

5 - Worst Driver
Chandhok. Spun and was woefully off the pace, coming in last behind both Virgin's and the HRT of Ricciardo. Heidfeld a close second for hitting Di Resta and then crashing out

6 - Worst Team
Well Ferrari cost Massa a position but you can't really say they're the worst team. Probably Williams. Abject again

7 - Best Rookie
No-one stood out, but Perez was the best of the rookies

8 - Biggest Surprise
Vettel's pace and racecraft. He just seemed to crumble today

9 - General Comment(s)
First 20 laps were stunning, next 40 were still tense. 8/10

gregg1966 · Post by **gregg1966** » 24 Jul 2011, 19:01

1 - Best Driver - Hamilton
2 - Best Team - still Red Bull
3 - Best Overtake - Hamilton on Webber,but crucial was on Alonso after his exit from last pitstop
4 - Best Moment - battle in the last lap in pitlane, Vettel out of podium for the first time
5 - Worst Driver - Chandhok
6 - Worst Team - HRT,Williams
7 - Best Rookie - Perez
8 - Biggest Surprise - Vettel unable to overtake Massa,it looks like RBR slowly loosing dominance

9 - General Comment(s) - decent race 8/10

alex1369 · Post by **alex1369** » 25 Jul 2011, 05:39

1 - Best Driver - Hamilton
2 - Best Team - Mclaren
3 - Best Overtake - Hamilton on Alonso, but he made it look so easy
after his move i just stand up from my bed and applauded
4 - Best Moment - Ham vs Alo, and Ham vs Web
5 - Worst Driver - Chandhok
6 - Worst Team - HRT,Williams
7 - Best Rookie - Perez
8 - Biggest Surprise - Hamilton winning when he said on friday they had no chance on pole - i hope he will lie like that every week

9 - General Comment(s) - very good race 9/10
HAM always wins cracking races

cformula1 · Post by **cformula1** » 25 Jul 2011, 06:59

1 - Best Driver
Lewis Hamilton
2 - Best Team
Force India
3 - Best Overtake
Hamilton on Alonso
4 - Best Moment
3-way battle for the lead
5 - Worst Driver
Buemi
6 - Worst Team
Williams
7 - Best Rookie
Perez
8 - Biggest Surprise
Vettel struggling

9 - General Comment(s)
Fantastic race, and it was a nice touch to see Webber give Alonso a ride home
9/10

dacer · Post by **dacer** » 25 Jul 2011, 07:43

1 - Best Driver, really no one deserve it. Maybe LH for win. Maybe Massa for "win" his battle with Vet, but first laps was bad, he can not overtake rosberg
2 - Best Team, not RBR, not McLaren, not Ferrari. So I will say HRT, both car finish and this for them is very good. I don't understand who write HRT as worse team, you only look final result and write last team. Maybe you must note about they budget and know for them, finish a race is a great result.
3 - Best Overtake, Massa to Vettel, and then Massa to other with Vettel shadow (not sure know, maybe was Kob and Petrov?)
4 - Best Moment, Web+Ham+Alo. But don't like see one driver pushing to the grass another.
5 - Worst Driver. Vettel. He show his skill here. He is a normal driver on the best car.
6 - Worst Team. Pirelli, his "hard" tyres only was there to photo on last lap .Ferrari, Why he always fails with Massa?. Maybe he loose faith on him, but ruins his race on last lap!!!
7 - Best Rookie
8 - Biggest Surprise

9 - General Comment(s)
Stupid tyres choice, soft tyres was enought hard, and hard tyres was too slow. They must use more agressive choice

Post by **phil1993** » 25 Jul 2011, 07:57

Liuzzi retired, so HRT only got one car to the end

dacer · Post by **dacer** » 25 Jul 2011, 08:03

phil1993 wrote:Liuzzi retired, so HRT only got one car to the end

true!!, but Ricciardo was not the last one

Eric_Cartman · Post by **Eric_Cartman** » 25 Jul 2011, 11:46

dacer wrote: 5 - Worst Driver. Vettel. He show his skill here. He is a normal driver on the best car.

Well, after 14 good races in a row, I think he can have one bad race

dacer · Post by **dacer** » 25 Jul 2011, 11:50

14 races, where win the car, not the driver. He is a bad driver when he has a little doubt. Remember how he ruins his race on Canada.

Eric_Cartman · Post by **Eric_Cartman** » 25 Jul 2011, 11:54

if only the car is responsible for his dominance, why isn't Mark Webber able to finish 2nd all the time?

dacer · Post by **dacer** » 25 Jul 2011, 12:09

not sure, maybe someone in his team don't want see him win, or maybe his blown diffuser didn't blow as strong as Vettel's one.

I'm going to think again my choice:
5 - Worst Driver
Top 6 drivers (RBR + McLaren + Ferrari)
1-LH, win the race, he is not worse driver
2-JB, beaten by his teammate, start 7, had a lot problems with petrov, and when he overtake him and Sutil, his car had problems, UNLUCKY, but not worse driver
3-FA, score a second place, was 4 on grid, is not worse driver
4-FM, beaten by his teammate, nice start, had a lot of problems with Rosberg, but on second half race, he overtake vettel, and get in front of him until last lap, when his mechanics ruins his race. Bad mechanics, but is not the worse driver
5-MW, start 1 and end 3, at least he get a podium, but is not a nice result.
6-SV, beaten by his teammate, overtake by FM, and he can overtake FM for a long time, when he look faster. And he had a mistake with his first tyres on lap 10, and was damaged, so he can drove fast until he replace it.

My choice is........, SV!!!

F1Zone