2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
- TwistedArmco
- F1 Driver
- Posts: 2010
- Joined: 30 May 2008, 18:44
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
You've got to ask yourself, if you were gifted a race in that way, what would you say to the media? You can't just say "yes, we just did team-orders".
No, I'm not calmer. Just more jaded.
-
- GP2 Driver
- Posts: 234
- Joined: 14 Mar 2008, 13:02
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
Maybe a coincidence, but if I didn't recall wrongly Hockenheim/Nurburgring was a turning point in the last few years of the drivers' and team championship..
Montoya win in Hockenheim in 2003 for Williams, Alonso and Webber win in 2005 and 2009 for Renault and Red Bull..
Should be an intriguing end to the championship
Montoya win in Hockenheim in 2003 for Williams, Alonso and Webber win in 2005 and 2009 for Renault and Red Bull..
Should be an intriguing end to the championship
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
Team orders should be allowed. I am quite in agreement with this principle. Teams should be allowed to control their results. May not be fair for the viewers and may create controversy and circus but teams should be allowed that. Like any company running their business.
HOWEVER...since 2002 team orders are "outlawed". That regulation should be canceled out of the sporting regs. But since it is in effect, I'd say run with it and penalize Ferrari and Alonso. Swap their finishing positions giving them the individual points they would have earned (Massa 1st place, Alonso 2nd place) and penalize the team by not awarding whatever points they won from their 1-2 finish.
HOWEVER...since 2002 team orders are "outlawed". That regulation should be canceled out of the sporting regs. But since it is in effect, I'd say run with it and penalize Ferrari and Alonso. Swap their finishing positions giving them the individual points they would have earned (Massa 1st place, Alonso 2nd place) and penalize the team by not awarding whatever points they won from their 1-2 finish.
Last edited by f1anatic on 25 Jul 2010, 14:12, edited 1 time in total.
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
Michael "Fernando seems to have stolen my strategy book"
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
iceman1 wrote:Michael "Fernando seems to have stolen my strategy book"
in general a boring race, even boring than Bahrain, hope i wont get a boring race when i will go to Hungary
P4 for my man is ok after a difficult weekend
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
I wouldn't mind team orders that much if they disguised it well enough. But to do it so blatantly and make up rubbish about Massa making a mistake upshifting is insulting to F1 fans intelligence.
The obvious nature of it I find much worse than the use of team orders, because every team does it. McLaren did it this way, telling Button to not race with Hamilton by telling him he had to save the car. I don't mind that, it was done with intelligence. Ferrari did it with stupidity, it was about as sly as hiding an elephant in a phone box.
The obvious nature of it I find much worse than the use of team orders, because every team does it. McLaren did it this way, telling Button to not race with Hamilton by telling him he had to save the car. I don't mind that, it was done with intelligence. Ferrari did it with stupidity, it was about as sly as hiding an elephant in a phone box.
- TwistedArmco
- F1 Driver
- Posts: 2010
- Joined: 30 May 2008, 18:44
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
Very well put.swca92 wrote:I wouldn't mind team orders that much if they disguised it well enough. But to do it so blatantly and make up rubbish about Massa making a mistake upshifting is insulting to F1 fans intelligence.
The obvious nature of it I find much worse than the use of team orders, because every team does it. McLaren did it this way, telling Button to not race with Hamilton by telling him he had to save the car. I don't mind that, it was done with intelligence. Ferrari did it with stupidity, it was about as sly as hiding an elephant in a phone box.
No, I'm not calmer. Just more jaded.
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
The most annoying thing about this is ferrari thinks the fans and press are stupid. Did you see massa at the press conference. And after that ferrari continues telling there were some problems for felipe, yeah right...disqualify them, maybe they will learn to be more clever instead of this childish behaviour.
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
I've just realised Jean Todt is the FIA president - if an appeal goes to the FIA courts he may well have the final verdict. If that happens my lungs may bust due to too much laughter, I may not be able to stop giggling for the next 20 years.
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
They should disqualify both drivers from the race standings along with the team
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
Massa - it was my decision to let Alonso pass
Ferrari - Massa did a mistake of shifting gears
Couldn't they agree on one/same variant?
Ferrari - Massa did a mistake of shifting gears
Couldn't they agree on one/same variant?
These Colours Don't Run!
Kimi, Always Kimi
Kimi, Always Kimi
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
team order will always happened in F1...but should do it cleverly.... what ferrari did today is clearly has firing back at them..
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
Massa says he feels he is not the team's focus for the championship
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
WTF .... I m shamed to be Ferrari .. like i was after Austria
I can only dislike Alonso.
I can only dislike Alonso.
Better than a thousand hollow words is one word that brings PEACE -Buddha
There is no point in defining a point... But there is a point in trying -Zack
[Videos]
Donate & support us
-ZACK- IO
There is no point in defining a point... But there is a point in trying -Zack
[Videos]
Donate & support us
-ZACK- IO
Re: 2010 Großer Preis Santander von Deutschland
from Twitter of NobleF1
Ferrari has been summoned to see the stewards following the German GP team orders controversy. More on autosport.com as it happens
Ferrari has been summoned to see the stewards following the German GP team orders controversy. More on autosport.com as it happens