Best F1 Rookie?

This forum gives you a chance to be able to communicate with your fellow F1 fans.

Best F1 rookie?

Jean Alesi (1989/90)
1
4%
Giancarlo Baghetti (1961)
1
4%
Emerson Fittipaldi (1970)
0
No votes
Lewis Hamilton (2007)
9
35%
Clay Regazzoni (1970)
0
No votes
Ayrton Senna (1984)
2
8%
Michael Schumacher (1991/2)
2
8%
Jackie Stewart (1965)
0
No votes
John Surtees (1960)
0
No votes
Sebastian Vettel (2007/8)
3
12%
Jacques Villeneuve (1996)
2
8%
Other (Please State)
6
23%
 
Total votes: 26

Tom Vandenhove
F1 Routinier
F1 Routinier
Posts: 3936
Joined: 09 Aug 2009, 10:50

Re: Best F1 Rookie?

Post by Tom Vandenhove » 25 Oct 2009, 14:01

Difficult question tbh.. I'd say that Jacques Villeneuve and Lewis Hamilton are a bit on the same level in their first year. Both were championship contenders and were 'better' than their teammate... But, my final vote goes to Vettel. Because I am sure that if he started his carreer in a car like a Williams-Renault (in 1996) or a McLaren (in 2007) he'd be the world champion.

davidh
car driver
car driver
Posts: 4
Joined: 21 Oct 2009, 15:29

Re: Best F1 Rookie?

Post by davidh » 26 Oct 2009, 15:08

MP4/4#12 wrote:
phil1993 wrote:Also, please:

Base this on their rookie year (and a half in some cases)
Base this on their impact in the sport
NO FANBOYISM please! Try and make this a fair poll, not just 'I dont like them so I'll vote for..


Ayrton Senna made impressive races with a Toleman

Michael Schumacher was impressive at Spa with the Jordan

No need to point their impact on the sport....it`s obvious.

All the others are ok, but most of them like Hamilton or Villeneuve started at top teams with fast cars, having already hundreds of milles of winter testing.


I was at Spa for Schumacher's first race, and as I recall he didn't even make it to the end of the start-finish straight. Yes, impressive in qualifying, but the racing is a different matter.

User avatar
blizzard
F1 Driver
F1 Driver
Posts: 1169
Joined: 15 Jun 2008, 15:07
Location: Duisburg, Germany

Re: Best F1 Rookie?

Post by blizzard » 26 Oct 2009, 15:26

Why isn´t Jim Clark included?

He was immediately amongst the quickest in whatever car he was driving. His impact on the sport was immense and his talent was beyond imagination.
Sir Jackie Stewart (one of the best himself) said various times that in his oppinion Jim Clark was the best.

So I say Jim Clark, you could put him into an Aston Martin and he was quickest, you could put him into an F1 car and he was quickest, you could put him into a coach and he was quickest...no matter what.

Hamilton and Villeneuve are a joke compared to Jim Clark.

Schumacher also wasn´t as good as Jim straight away.

The only driver who entered F1 in a similar fashion was Senna.


The fact that 40% voted for Hamilton shows once again how deluded a lot of people are these days.
Image

amoljoshi
F1 Rookie
F1 Rookie
Posts: 593
Joined: 15 Mar 2008, 07:11
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
Contact:

Re: Best F1 Rookie?

Post by amoljoshi » 26 Oct 2009, 16:35

As I was a Schumi Fan when he was there, I always found Kimi a threat to Schumi.

I`ll vote for Kimi as the best Rookie.

User avatar
harius
car driver
car driver
Posts: 5
Joined: 27 Oct 2009, 11:46

Re: Best F1 Rookie?

Post by harius » 28 Oct 2009, 21:02

Since I watch f1 I´ve never seen a rookie as competitive as hamilton. He could fight perfectly with alonso, actually, he was better than alonso in the first half of 2007 season (as well as alonso was better than him in the second half). He almost won the championship and finished in the same points as alonso, that has much merit for a rookie.
So I vote for Hamilton.

User avatar
sato113
kart driver
kart driver
Posts: 37
Joined: 02 Dec 2009, 20:38

Re: Best F1 Rookie?

Post by sato113 » 07 Dec 2009, 19:18

Kobayashi- only 2 races, but didn't crumble under pressure like most rookies.

User avatar
Coopz
F1 Rookie
F1 Rookie
Posts: 856
Joined: 10 Oct 2009, 11:12

Re: Best F1 Rookie?

Post by Coopz » 07 Dec 2009, 20:11

I don't think you can judge somebody on two races.
Image

User avatar
HandoZiZle
GP2 Driver
GP2 Driver
Posts: 278
Joined: 26 Nov 2007, 01:42
Location: Houston, America
Contact:

Re: Best F1 Rookie?

Post by HandoZiZle » 07 Dec 2009, 20:47

I would vote for Montoya but since he's not on the list, i voted for Hamilton.
Image

Post Reply